Question 40e7db

1.2 Command of Evidence - Evidence that refutes or qualifies a claim
0:00
1,3001,2001,1001,0009008007006005004003002001000Number of municipalitiesno responseresponded to inquiryoffered incentiveMunicipalities Responses to Inquiries about Potential Incentives for Firm announcement before election announcement after election
  • For each data egory, the following bars are shown:�
    • announcement before election
    • announcement after election
  • The data for the 3 egories are as follows:�
    • no response:
      • announcement before election: 1,252
      • announcement after election: 1,248
    • responded to inquiry:
      • announcement before election: 207
      • announcement after election: 205
    • offered incentive:
      • announcement before election: 128
      • announcement after election: 122

In the United States, firms often seek incentives from municipal governments to expand to those municipalities. A team of political scientists hypothesized that municipalities are much more likely to respond to firms and offer incentives if expansions can be announced in time to benefit local elected officials than if they cant. The team contacted officials in thousands of municipalities, inquiring about incentives for a firm looking to expand and indiing that the firm would announce its expansion on a date either just before or just after the next election.�

Which choice best describes data from the graph that weaken the team’s hypothesis?

A.

A large majority of the municipalities that received an inquiry mentioning plans for an announcement before the next election didn’t respond to the inquiry.

B.

The proportion of municipalities that responded to the inquiry or offered incentives didn’t substantially differ across the announcement timing conditions. 

C.

Only around half the municipalities that responded to inquiries mentioning plans for an announcement before the next election offered incentives. 

D.

Of the municipalities that received an inquiry mentioning plans for an announcement date after the next election, more than 1,200 didn’t respond and only around 100 offered incentives.